When “Resource Guarding” Wasn’t the Whole Story
A newly adopted Chihuahua, a family weighing whether to give her up, and the detail that didn’t fit the obvious explanation.
The situation
Rosa had just adopted Lola when things escalated fast. In the first days in their new home, Lola air snapped at Rosa’s son twice — once over a toy, once with nothing in her mouth at all. Rosa was frightened, exhausted, and seriously weighing whether Lola could stay.
The stakes
This wasn’t a minor training hiccup. Rosa was becoming afraid of what Lola might do next, torn between wanting to keep her and not trusting the situation was safe. Ordinary life — her son playing normally in his own home, having visitors over, even walking Lola — had become something to carefully manage rather than enjoy.
Looking beyond the label
Most of what Lola was doing looked like classic resource guarding: socks, toys, even the couch. But two details didn’t add up. Lola would sometimes climb into Rosa’s lap while holding a guarded item — comfort-seeking and defending, at the same time. And she was mouthing and carrying objects that had no real value to a dog, in a way that looked more soothing than possessive.
What we found
Investigation, not diagnosis
- Behavioral — the guarding had generalized across objects, and even to eye contact alone with no approach needed. That pointed to Lola’s emotional response to people near anything she valued, not the value of the items themselves.
- Environmental & relational — an abrupt rehoming, no prior experience with children, and very limited early socialization in her previous home.
- Physical — Lola wouldn’t let anyone near her face or snout. That’s not something to diagnose from a living room, so I recommended a veterinary check early to rule out oral pain.
The vet check confirmed significant dental disease. Lola underwent surgery to remove eight teeth.
The plan
We worked on three fronts at once: safety and management, so no one was forcing interactions or reaching for guarded items; a structured “drop it” protocol built slowly from low-value objects up to the things Lola actually guarded; and the dental treatment and follow-up medication support recommended by her vet. Rosa and her son also learned to read Lola’s body language — what stiffness, freezing, and avoidance actually mean — so they could respond before things escalated rather than after.
Where they are now
Lola — who once wouldn’t tolerate a hand near her face — now rests on Rosa’s shoulders and lets her brush her teeth. She has attended a children’s birthday party and stayed relaxed around a group of kids. Rosa can now read Lola’s early warning signs herself, which has changed the day-to-day feel of living together.
What this proves
Treating the guarding as the whole problem would have missed the pain that was quietly making everything else harder. Looking at Lola’s full context — history, relationships, environment, and physical health — is what actually moved this case forward.
I never told Rosa that Lola would never guard again, and I still wouldn’t. What changed is that the family now knows how to prevent it, catch it early, and keep everyone safe — and that’s what made it possible for Lola to stay exactly where she belongs.
Is your dog’s behavior not quite adding up?
That mismatch is often the most useful clue you have. A Behavior Clarity Assessment is built to dig into it.
Book a call